Comer v. Scott and Texas Education Agency

All the legal documentation available to us for the case of Christina Castillo Comer v. Robert Scott, in his official capacity as commissioner of the Texas Education Agency, and the Texas Education Agency is provided at the bottom of this page. It is arranged in chronological order.

The ruling dismissing the case can be downloaded here.

Audio of the oral argument from the appeal can be downloaded here (WMA file)

Related NCSE Articles

Multimedia: Chris Comer: Expelled for Real

News: Barbara Forrest on Chris Comer's forced resignation

News: The latest on the Comer controversy

News: Science Supervisor Chris Comer Sues Texas Education Agency

News: Comer case dismissed

News: Chris Comer appeals

News: Comer appeal heard

PDF icon 6/30/08: Original Complaint3.01 MB
PDF icon 8/11/08: Defendants' original answer867.28 KB
PDF icon 8/11/08: Defendants' motion to dismiss3.84 MB
PDF icon 9/18/08: Memorandum of points and authorities in support of Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment and in opposition to Defendant's motion to dismiss3.41 MB
PDF icon 10/17/08: Defendants' opposition, with brief, to Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment1006.51 KB
PDF icon 10/17/08: Plaintiff's opposition to Defendants' motion for summary judgment175.01 KB
PDF icon 11/14/08: Defendant's reply in support of summary judgment697.12 KB
PDF icon 11/14/08: Plaintiff's reply in support of motion for summary judgment798.4 KB
PDF icon 12/24/08: Plaintiff's motion for leave to supplement Plaintiff's statement of material undisputed facts140.5 KB
PDF icon 12/24/08: Plaintiff's supplement to statement of undisputed material facts63.3 KB
PDF icon 1/5/09: Amended Rule CV-7(h) conference certification42.84 KB
PDF icon 2/17/09: Defendant's unopposed request for the Court to take judicial notice of proposed rules3.9 MB
PDF icon 2/18/09: Order granting Defendant's request for judicial notice of proposed rules25.28 KB
PDF icon 2/19/09: Plaintiff's response to Defendant's unopposed request to take judicial notice of proposed rules78.14 KB
PDF icon 2/27/09: Defendant's advisory to the Court of new authority1.25 MB
PDF icon 3/3/09: Plaintiff's response to Defendant's advisory to the Court of new authority72.86 KB
PDF icon 3/31/09: Memorandum, opinion, and order on motion to dismiss and motions for summary judgment798.5 KB
PDF icon 4/30/09: Notice of Appeal49.52 KB
PDF icon 8/6/09: Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Record Excerpts1.2 MB
PDF icon 8/6/09: Brief of Appellant (Plaintiff)208.9 KB
PDF icon 10/15/09: Brief of Appellees1.09 MB
PDF icon 11/13/09: Appellant's reply brief59.85 KB
File 04/26/10: Oral Arguments (WMA)19.79 MB
PDF icon 7/2/10: Opinion263.46 KB