You are hereEvolution in the Sunshine State: The Fight Over Evolution in the State Science StandardsTitle: Evolution in the Sunshine State: The Fight Over Evolution in the State Science Standards Issue: 4 It is educational and exciting to witness firsthand the evertwisting plot that arises in battles over evolution education. I joined with other Florida Citizens for Science (FCS) members and our associates in the Florida capital, Tallahassee, February 19, 2008, when the board of education met to decide the fate of a brand new set of state science education standards (see RNCSE 2008 Mar/Apr; 28 [2]: 4–7). Year: 2008 Date: July–August Page(s): 28-31 This version might differ slightly from the print publication. Media Type: Texas Textbook Adoptions: Whither (Wither) Evolution?Texas is the largest single purchaser of textbooks in the nation, thus what Texas wants in its textbooks strongly influences what other states get. In past years, evolution was systematically deleted or downplayed in textbooks because Texas required textbooks to print a disclaimer that any textbook dealing with evolution.
Media Type: topics: Evolution Challenged in Colorado's Largest School DistrictThis June an ad-hoc committee of the Jefferson County, Colorado schools, a Denver area school district, responded to Wheat Ridge High School sophomore Danny Phillips's complaints about evolution education by recommending that teachers stop using a videotape, "The Miracle of Life," and have it removed from the district resource center. Phillips had complained about more than the videotape, a film about human reproduction which opens by discussing the common ancestry of all life. Media Type: topics: Good, Bad, and Lots of Indifferent: State K–12 Science StandardsTitle: Good, Bad, and Lots of Indifferent: The State of State K–12 Science Education Standards Issue: 3 Curriculum standards have many important applications. They are used as guidelines by curriculum developers, by textbook publishers, and by examination writers, among other things. I was first asked by the Thomas B Fordham Foundation to evaluate the science education standards of every state that had them in 1997. I surveyed 36 documents — a pretty dull but (I hope) useful task (Lerner 1998). Year: 2008 Date: May–June Page(s): 19–22 This version might differ slightly from the print publication. Media Type: Review: Making Sense of EvolutionYear: 2008 Title: Making Sense of Evolution: The Conceptual Foundations of Evolutionary Biology Issue: 3 Making Sense of Evolution is an ambitious book synthesizing the views of a practicing biologist (Massimo Pigliucci) with those of a practicing philosopher of biology (Jonathan Kaplan). It begins with central concepts in evolution that are referred to throughout the book, and then moves on to such topics as how to measure natural selection, the debate over the units or "levels" of selection, adaptationism, functions, testing adaptive hypotheses in human evolution, and the concept of species. Date: May–June Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006. 300 pages. Page(s): 28–29 ReferencesBeatty J. 1984. Chance and natural selection. Philosophy of Science 51: 183–211.Matthen M, Ariew A. 2002. Two ways of thinking about fitness and natural selection. The Journal of Philosophy 99: 55–83. Millstein RL. 2002. Are random drift and natural selection conceptually distinct? Biology and Philosophy 17 (1): 33–53. Pigliucci M. 2002. Denying Evolution: Creationism, Scientism, and the Nature of Science. Sunderland (MA): Sinauer Associates. This version might differ slightly from the print publication. Media Type: Review: The Evolving WorldYear: 2008 Title: The Evolving World: Evolution in Everyday Life Issue: 3 Date: May–June The Evolving World was a book that needed to be written and ought to be read by everyone — but particularly those of us who promote evolution education to the general public. The main message for this audience is that other scientific theories, such as germ theory and heliocentrism, that are now widely — though perhaps not universally — accepted among the general public took much longer to gain acceptance than has evolution — at least so far. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press, 2006. 341 pages. Page(s): 27–28 Media Type: This version might differ slightly from the print publication. Review: Creation and Evolution: A Conference with Pope Benedict XVIYear: 2008 Title: Creation and Evolution: A Conference with Pope Benedict XVI in Castel Gandolfo Issue: 3 Awaited with curiosity since initial news reports of this meeting, this book proves doubly disappointing. It is regrettable that top Catholic leaders seem drawn toward "intelligent design" (ID); but it is disturbing that they seem not even aware of relevant and better thinking within their own church. Date: May–June Page(s): 25–27 San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2008. 210 pages. ReferencesDomning DP. 2002a. Evolutionary theology comes of age. Reports of the National Center for Science Education 21 (3–4): 34–7.Domning DP. 2002b. Doing Without Adam and Eve: Sociobiology and Original Sin by Patricia A Williams [review]. Reports of the National Center for Science Education 22 (4): 31–2. Maynard Smith J, Szathmáry E. 1995. The Major Transitions in Evolution. Oxford: WH Freeman, 1995. Phillips RP. 1948. Modern Thomistic Philosophy: An Explanation for Students. Vol. I. The Philosophy of Nature. Westminster (MD): Newman Press. This version might differ slightly from the print publication. topics: Media Type: Creationism Slips Into a Peer-Reviewed JournalTitle: Creationism Slips Into a Peer-Reviewed Journal Issue: 3 A strange thing happened in the scientific literature recently. A pair of creationists, who have seemingly legitimate scientific credentials, attempted to publish some creationist assertions in a peer-reviewed journal. Their effort was nearly successful, mostly because they hid their pseudoscience in the middle of the article, surrounded by legitimate scientific discussion of unrelated topics. Luckily, they were caught just in time, and it turned out that they were pretty clumsy. In fact, if they had been just a bit more clever, they might have gotten away with it. Year: 2008 Date: May–June Page(s): 12–14, 19 This version might differ slightly from the print publication. Media Type: RNCSE 28 (3)
Issue: 3 Year: 2008 Date: May–June Articles available online are listed below.
Click "Print Edition Contents" for list of articles in the print edition. Media Type: History Forum Addresses Creation/Evolution ControversyTitle: History Forum Addresses Creation/Evolution Controversy Issue: 5 Every year, the University of Alabama in Huntsville (UAH) History Department presents a series of four programs on a topic of current interest such as turmoil in the middle east and the break-up of the Soviet bloc, Recently the creation/evolution controversy was considered to be sufficiently important and interesting to be the central topic. Year: 1997 Date: September–October Page(s): 12–16 This version might differ slightly from the print publication. Media Type: Pages |